Anti-smoking foundation loses final ruling on 'cheating cigarettes'
The Dutch Trade and Industry Appeals Tribunal has ruled against the anti-smoking organization Rookpreventie Jeugd regarding their request to change cigarette testing methods. The court determined that tobacco manufacturers are legally bound to use the established measurement standard, effectively dismissing claims about so-called cheat cigarettes. The foundation expressed disappointment, noting that the ruling avoids addressing the health risks associated with how filters affect smoke intake.
In 2018, the anti-smoking organization Rookpreventie Jeugd urged the Netherlands Food and Consumer Product Safety Authority to adopt a different testing method for cigarettes. The organization argued that the standard method fails to account for how smokers' fingers and lips cover ventilation holes in filters, leading to the inhalation of significantly higher levels of tar, nicotine, and carbon monoxide. Studies by the RIVM indicated that actual intake could be fifteen times higher than official figures suggest. However, the Trade and Industry Appeals Tribunal recently ruled against the foundation. Citing a European Court of Justice decision, the tribunal confirmed that manufacturers are legally required to use only the established industry measurement method. Industry representatives welcomed the ruling, stating it validates their current practices and denies the existence of so-called cheat cigarettes. Foundation chair Wanda de Kanter expressed disappointment, arguing that the court prioritized procedural details over the actual health impacts. She claims that tobacco companies will continue using filters that render cigarettes more addictive and harmful than European regulations intended, leaving the core health issue unaddressed by the legal system.
Based on reporting by nu. Translated and condensed by LocalHeadlines.
