Judge: Fons Vitae Lyceum does not have to promote Kevin (13) to 8th grade

A judge in Amsterdam has ruled that the Fons Vitae Lyceum acted correctly in refusing to promote 13-year-old student Kevin to the second year of havo. The school based its decision on the student's four failing grades, as well as observations regarding his work pace and comprehension of the curriculum. The court determined that the school followed proper procedures, provided sufficient language support, and offered extra opportunities for retakes that are not standard for first-year students. Despite the student having struggled with personal issues, including bullying and family illness, the judge found that the school’s decision-making process was thorough and well-supported.

The student's mother had argued that the school failed to adequately support her son, citing his language barrier and the impact of his personal circumstances. She requested that he be moved to the next grade and expressed deep disappointment with the ruling, stating she may consider an appeal. The school had suggested an alternative placement at a bilingual school, which the family declined. The judge ordered the mother to pay over 2,100 euros in legal costs.